The Cost of High Turnover in 3PL

High staff turnover in 3PL is an ongoing problem for many companies, with significant costs incurred. The logistics industry is heavily reliant on efficiency (which extends to the workforce) in order to maintain smooth operations. Frequent staffing changes can lead to significant disruptions that impact productivity, service delivery and profitability.

What are the direct costs associated with employee turnover?

Replacing employees can be a costly exercise, and while companies tend to focus on the cost of recruitment, the financial implications can extend far beyond this. Consider this:

The average turnover cost for an employee earning £25k or more sits around the £30.5k mark, however, for more senior positions the cost of replacement can range anywhere between £40-100k per person. Best estimates often put the cost of replacing an employee between 6-9 months of their salary.

These costs can stem from a variety of factors; advertising job openings, agency fees, onboarding costs and lost productivity in transition periods. Yet in addition to the costs associated with recruitment, employers in the UK invest an average of £1,500+ per employee annually on training and development, where frequent turnover results in repeated training expenses.

What are the indirect costs & operational impact associated with employee turnover?

While it’s easier to measure direct costs, the indirect costs of high turnover in 3PL are often more debilitating over time. Frequent turnover can result in:

Decreased productivity when factoring in the time it takes to onboard a new employee and have them reach full efficiency; with this transitionary period experiencing lost productivity as a result of training. The problem with a revolving workforce is its effect on service quality and accuracy, in turn leading to delays and reputational damage. 

Lost industry knowledge; where employees who leave take critical knowledge of workflows, processes and best practices. It takes time to build up this knowledge once lost - potentially impacting efficiency, productivity and profitability. A higher turnover rate can also be quite damaging to employee morale, which fosters disengagement and resentment among existing employees required to pick up the slack.

Why is employee turnover unique in 3PL?

The logistics sector suffers from unique challenges that makes staff turnover particularly costly, given the fast paced environment in which efficiency and accuracy are needed to meet tight deadlines. Frequent staff changes increase the risk of:

Operational disruptions like order fulfilment errors, missed deliveries, and increased customer complaints,

Damaged client relationships; where a fluctuating workforce can lead to weakened trust in service reliability, contract losses, and increased client churn.

Competitive disadvantages; companies struggling with higher turnover may struggle in maintaining existing client partnerships or securing new ones, with potential clients hesitating to partner with a provider they perceive to be unstable. This in turn will ultimately affect revenue growth and reputation within the industry.

How can 3PLs mitigate the impact of turnover?

While turnover can ultimately be inevitable, there are steps a company can take to reduce its frequency and impact:

Offer competitive compensation packages - Retention will often come down to fair wages, a strong benefits package and performance incentives, ensuring that employees feel valued and fairly compensated.

Create identifiable career progression paths - Your workforce would be more likely to stay with the company if they see opportunities for growth and advancement. Development pathways and structured promotion paths can encourage career longevity. 

Investments in employee development - Continuous learning and development can both enhance job satisfaction and create a skilled workforce better equipped to handle changes and evolution within the industry. 

Foster a positive work environment - Supportive, accessible and inclusive working environments can boost employee morale, reduce dissatisfaction and improve engagement; all necessary components for the retention and development of key employees.

Leverage the use of technology and automation - Automation across transport and logistics operations can serve to reduce the dependency on physical and manual labour; mitigating the impact and frequency of turnover, while increasing accuracy and efficiency.

High staff turnover across the UKs 3PL sector represents a significant challenge; from financial loss to operational inefficiencies. Addressing this will require a strategic focus on employee satisfaction, stability and retention. The implementation of competitive benefits, career development opportunities and leveraging the power of technology will enable 3PL companies to reduce turnover, and maintain a competitive advantage in an increasingly demanding labour market.

‍