Higher Education Can’t Afford Another Patchwork Fix

Universities in the UK are contending with some of the most serious challenges of their modern history. Long lauded as global leaders in teaching, learning and research, institutions across the country now grapple with deep rooted structural issues that threaten their continuity. 

From workforce pressures to regulatory complexity, financial fragility and shifting societal expectations, the Higher Education (HE) sector is under strain from all sides. With shifting economic uncertainty, there is a growing consensus that the sector can no longer afford to absorb further short term fixes. What is needed is a strategic, long term rethink into how universities are funded, managed and supported to meet growing expectations.

At the centre of the current crisis is a funding model that no longer represents the current economic reality. Domestic tuition fees have remained frozen at £9,250 since 2017 but the cost of delivering undergraduate education has increased dramatically. Universities UK estimates that institutions are losing in excess of £2,500 per student each year; a shortfall that is becoming increasingly unsustainable.

In an attempt to bridge the gap, many universities are turning to international students, whose higher fees have helped to bolster budgets. Yes this strategy introduces new vulnerabilities. Tighter visa restrictions, geopolitical tension and growing global competition (Australia and Canada, in particular) has led to a decline in international applicants, and further exposed the fragility of this cross subsidy model. For many universities, the financial buffers are eroding and deficits are beginning to show.

Recalibrating student expectations

The question around what students are expecting - and what they actually receive - from their university experience is becoming increasingly central to public discourse. Following pandemic era disruptions and a rapid shift to blended or remote learning, many students have grown more vocal about demanding value for money, clearer employment pathways and better mental health support. 

Public and political scrutiny of the sector has only intensified, with increasing pressure on universities to demonstrate return on investment for its students and the taxpayer. This has led to calls for more transparency and accountability around course content, contact hours and graduate prospects. Yet a growing concern remains that a purely consumer driven model risks reducing HE to a transactional experience, undermining its role in fostering social cohesion, critical thinking and lifelong learning. As universities recalibrate their offering, they must grapple with meeting student demands while preserving the integrity and long term value of a university education.

The Office for Students has responded; tightening its focus on outcomes, particularly graduate employment and salary data as key indicators of course quality. But such a data driven approach has its limitations and may risk overlooking the broadening civic and educational missions driving universities. Finding the balance between academic integrity with employability, while ensuring inclusive and accessible learning opportunities, will remain a key challenge for universities and policymakers alike.

Although there has been progress in increasing participation, there are still major obstacles to overcome in order to address disparities in outcomes, attainment, and access. The cost-of-living crisis has increased financial strains on students worldwide, and students from underprivileged backgrounds still encounter difficulties navigating the Higher Education system.

Additionally, there is mounting pressure on universities to address the student mental health crisis. Although the demand for support services has increased, many institutions are ill-equipped to meet this demand. Retention, success, and the legitimacy of higher education's social mission all depend on addressing these problems, which goes beyond student welfare.

Navigating workforce instability, research funding & the changing academic profession

The sustainability of the HE workforce is also under tremendous pressure; with recruitment and retention becoming a significant challenge in both academic and professional services roles. Brexit related immigration policies have made it more difficult to attract international talent, particularly in research disciplines. Prolonged periods of below-inflation pay, rising workloads, and widespread casualisation are contributing to growing staff dissatisfaction and industrial unrest. 

The nature of the academic profession is also evolving, with universities increasingly required to deliver on a complex range of functions: teaching, commercial partnerships and research, often with limited resources. As is the case in most industries, staff are being asked to do more, with less, in what many are describing as an unsustainable effort.

The UK’s position as a leader in global research is also under strain from changes to international and domestic funding. The disruption caused by the UK’s delayed re-entry into Horizon Europe (the EU’s flagship research and innovation programme, running from 2022-27) undermines trust and interrupts collaboration, despite an eventual agreement to rejoin. While such a return is welcome, confidence in long term research stability remains fragile.

Domestically, income from research is becoming increasingly concentrated in a small number of institutions, while many others struggle to maintain research activity. Smaller universities; those outside of metropolitan areas, report difficulty in accessing funding or maintaining partnerships. Such an uneven distribution risks deepening regional inequality and further weakening the broader national research ecosystem.

The challenges facing universities in the UK are not isolated, nor are they short term. They reflect a sector stuck in transition - caught between legacy and future demands. With a new government in office, there is a real need for a strategic, longer term vision for higher education that supports its role as a key driver in social mobility, economic growth and continued innovation.

That vision must be backed by funding policies that reflect the real expense of teaching and research, a regulatory approach that supports autonomy and quality, alongside a commitment to creating opportunities for all. Without this, the risk will not simply be institutions struggling, but that the UK will lose one of its most valuable national assets.

The road ahead requires courage and fortitude, from policymakers, sector leaders and universities alike. Reactive policy and piecemeal solutions can no longer suffice in a system already stretched to breaking point. To secure a sustainable future, Higher Education must move beyond patchwork fixes and commit to a coherent, long term settlement that recognises the complexity and value that it brings to society; equipping it with the tools and resources that it needs to thrive in an increasingly competitive global arena.

‍